The Real Reason PSLV Exists: When Owning the Metal Matters More Than Returns

The article explains that Sprott Physical Silver Trust (PSLV) is structured to provide direct, allocated exposure to physical silver—effectively owning ounces in vault—rather than derivative or income-generating strategies. That structure has market implications: PSLV delivers purer price exposure but has trailed iShares Silver Trust (SLV) over multiple horizons due to premium compression, costing roughly 7 percentage points over one year and ~48 points over ten years. PSLV’s $19.7 billion in assets, 0.45% expense ratio, redemption-for-physical feature, and U.S. tax treatment (potentially long-term capital gains via QEF election) make it attractive to investors prioritizing counterparty risk reduction and tax efficiency. For traders focused purely on silver price returns, SLV’s lower structural drag has historically produced higher total returns. Premium/discount dynamics and silver’s volatility (PSLV +7% last week) remain key risks influencing investor outcomes.